Real tree or fake tree? Elf or Home Alone? Here are 160 Christmas This or That questions in 7 lists: traditions, food, movies and music, kids, gifts, office parties, and winter and New Year. Everyone picks a side at the same time, then the room argues it out. Play a round here, print the page, or open the free game with the Christmas theme already on.
Every list is family-safe. Start with traditions or food, use the kids list in class, and save the office list for the team party or the last meeting before the break.
Christmas traditions
Real tree or fake tree?
Decorate after Thanksgiving or in December?
Open gifts on Christmas Eve or Christmas morning?
White lights or colored lights?
Star or angel on top of the tree?
Stockings by the fireplace or on the bed?
Advent calendar or countdown chain?
Wrapping paper or gift bags?
Christmas cards or Christmas texts?
Big family Christmas or small and cozy?
Carols at home or caroling door to door?
Matching pajamas or ugly sweaters?
Secret Santa or White Elephant?
Elf on the Shelf or no elf at all?
Midnight service or Christmas morning service?
Snow globe or nutcracker?
Ornaments from trips or matching ornaments?
Wreath on the door or lights on the roof?
Gingerbread house or sugar cookies?
Christmas photo with the family or with the pet?
Hang mistletoe or skip it?
Train under the tree or village under the tree?
Leave out cookies or carrots?
Christmas in the city or in the countryside?
Tinsel or garland?
Christmas food and drinks
Hot cocoa or eggnog?
Turkey or ham?
Gingerbread or shortbread?
Candy canes or chocolate coins?
Mince pie or Christmas pudding?
Marshmallows or whipped cream on cocoa?
Peppermint bark or fudge?
Roast potatoes or mashed potatoes?
Christmas cookies or Christmas cake?
Mulled wine or hot apple cider?
Cranberry sauce or gravy?
Yule log or cheesecake?
Breakfast casserole or cinnamon rolls on Christmas morning?
Popcorn garland or candy garland?
Fruitcake or panettone?
Christmas dinner at noon or in the evening?
Leftovers for days or nothing left over?
Chocolate orange or candy cane?
Pigs in a blanket or cheese board?
Sugar cookies with icing or with sprinkles?
Gingerbread latte or peppermint mocha?
Brussels sprouts or green beans?
Stuffing or dinner rolls?
Hot chocolate bombs or classic cocoa?
Bake cookies or eat cookies?
Christmas movies and music
Elf or Home Alone?
The Grinch or A Charlie Brown Christmas?
The Polar Express or Frozen?
Mariah Carey or Michael Bublé?
Jingle Bells or Silent Night?
Christmas movie marathon or one classic?
Rudolph or Frosty?
A Christmas Carol or Miracle on 34th Street?
The Santa Clause or Jingle All the Way?
Christmas music in November or only in December?
Love Actually or The Holiday?
Animated or live action Christmas movies?
Karaoke carols or Christmas playlist?
Nutcracker ballet or Christmas concert?
Old classics or new Christmas songs?
Hallmark movies or action movies at Christmas?
All I Want for Christmas Is You or Last Christmas?
Watch with popcorn or with cookies?
Rudolph's nose or Frosty's hat?
Scrooge before or after the ghosts?
Christmas This or That for kids
Santa or the Grinch?
Reindeer or elves?
Snowman or snow angel?
Sledding or snowball fight?
Write to Santa or visit Santa?
Rudolph or Dasher?
Ride the sleigh or drive the toy train?
North Pole or Gingerbread Land?
Toy workshop or reindeer stable?
Candy cane or gingerbread man?
Build a snow fort or a snowman?
Elf hat or Santa hat?
Jingle bells or sleigh bells?
Wake up early or sleep in on Christmas morning?
Help Santa wrap or help Santa deliver?
Penguins or polar bears?
Decorate the tree or decorate cookies?
Christmas lights drive or Christmas parade?
Christmas story or Christmas song?
Stay up for Santa or go to bed early?
Snowflakes or icicles?
Christmas pajamas or Christmas sweater?
Make a paper chain or a paper snowflake?
Be an elf for a day or a reindeer for a day?
Snow day or Christmas Day?
Christmas gifts and shopping
Shop early or shop at the last minute?
Online shopping or mall shopping?
Gift cards or wrapped gifts?
Homemade gifts or store-bought gifts?
Practical gift or fun gift?
Wish list or surprise?
Wrap gifts yourself or pay for gift wrap?
Spend more on fewer gifts or less on more gifts?
Experience gift or something to keep?
Open gifts one at a time or all at once?
Re-gift or return?
Matching gifts for everyone or a different gift for each?
Tag with names or guess who it is for?
Stocking stuffers or one big gift?
Black Friday deals or Christmas Eve rush?
Gift receipt or no receipt?
Shake the box or wait to open it?
Bows on top or no bows?
Shop with a list or shop by feel?
Give or receive?
Office Christmas party This or That
Office party at lunch or after work?
Ugly sweater contest or costume contest?
Secret Santa or no gifts?
Potluck or catered food?
Christmas karaoke or Christmas trivia?
Decorate your desk or keep it simple?
Team dinner or team activity?
Gift under $20 or under $50?
Festive Zoom background or plain background?
Holiday bonus or extra day off?
Christmas sweater on video calls or Santa hat on video calls?
Cookie swap or chili cook-off?
Out-of-office on Dec 23 or answer emails until Dec 24?
Christmas playlist at work or quiet office?
Bring the treats or eat the treats?
Office party games or office party dancing?
Give a toast or hide from the toast?
Last day before the break: half day or long lunch?
Holiday cards from the team or holiday video message?
Gingerbread contest or snowflake contest?
Reindeer antlers or elf ears for the day?
Plan the party or just show up?
Festive desk lights or festive door decorations?
Gift exchange by name draw or by number draw?
New Year resolutions shared or kept private?
Winter and New Year
Snow or sunshine on Christmas Day?
Ice skating or skiing?
Cozy cabin or city lights?
Fireplace or heated blanket?
Mittens or gloves?
Midnight countdown or asleep by ten?
New Year's party or quiet night in?
Fireworks or sparklers?
Resolutions or no resolutions?
Hot tub in the snow or sauna?
Winter walk or winter nap?
Scarf or hat?
Christmas break trip or stay home?
Boxing Day sales or Boxing Day leftovers?
Snowed in with family or with friends?
Take down decorations on Dec 26 or in January?
Champagne or sparkling cider at midnight?
Kiss at midnight or hug at midnight?
Winter wonderland or tropical getaway?
Count down to Christmas or count down to New Year?
How to use this collection
How to play This or That: Christmas edition
Read a question out loud. On three, everyone points left for the first option or right for the second. No "both". Ask someone from the smaller side to defend the pick, then move on. Ten questions fill about five minutes, which makes it a good warm-up before gifts, dinner or a longer party game.
Christmas brain break for the classroom
Give each option a move: jumping jacks for the first, arm circles for the second, or walk to the left or right wall. Read from the kids list, or project this page and let the class vote with their whole body. It works as a five-minute brain break between lessons in December.
Office party and video call version
Post one question a day in the team chat as a poll, or open the office list at the party. On a video call, share the CardYard tab and let people vote with reactions. For a vote on every phone with the split revealed at once, start a Room and share the code.
Make it a family competition
Before each reveal, one person guesses what the majority will pick. A right guess scores a point. Or pair up and guess your partner's answer. Grandparents against grandkids is a classic match-up for tree, music and food questions.
Questions, answered
What are good Christmas This or That questions?
Quick picks between two festive things everyone has an opinion on: "real tree or fake tree?", "Elf or Home Alone?", "open gifts on Christmas Eve or Christmas morning?". This page has 160 of them in 7 lists.
Are these Christmas This or That questions good for kids?
Yes. Every question on the page is family-safe, and the kids list has 25 simple picks like "reindeer or elves?" and "sledding or snowball fight?" for classrooms and family nights.
How do you play This or That: Christmas edition?
Read two options, everyone picks at the same time, then one person explains. In class, give each option a move to make it a brain break. At a party, count who guessed the majority right.
Can I play Christmas This or That online?
Yes. Open the free CardYard game with the Christmas theme to draw fresh two-choice questions on one screen or a video call, or start a Room so everyone votes on their own phone.
Can I print this list?
Yes. Print the page or copy any list with its button. The questions read well aloud without a screen.
What is the difference from Christmas Would You Rather?
This or That is a quick pick between two things, like "turkey or ham?". Christmas Would You Rather asks bigger festive dilemmas with a catch. Both use the same vote, so mix them in one round.