Skip to content

Christmas Would You Rather

Christmas Would You Rather questions worth debating

These 80 Christmas Would You Rather questions give both sides of the room a real choice. Start with easy questions for kids, move into family traditions and party mishaps, or open the free generator with Christmas already selected.

Play Christmas Would You RatherBrowse all games
More options: choose another christmas game

Use this guide

Make the round work.

  1. 01

    Make both options equally tempting

    The best questions compare the same tradeoff: two foods, two traditions, two powers, or two party jobs. Random unrelated options end the debate too quickly.

  2. 02

    Let people explain their choice

    Ask everyone to choose a side before anyone argues. The explanation is the game, especially when family traditions and gift habits divide the room.

  3. 03

    Use one phone or read from the list

    The host can draw fresh cards in the browser, or the group can work through the visible questions without accounts, downloads, or AI requests.

  4. 04

    Keep the Christmas category family-safe

    The free Christmas deck avoids adult material and works for children, mixed-age families, classrooms, office parties, and video calls.

Prompt starters

Ideas to pull from fast.

Use a list as a starting point, then open the game when you want the round to run itself.

Christmas Would You Rather for kids

  • Have a pet reindeer OR a pet polar bear
  • Build a giant snow fort OR a giant gingerbread house
  • Wear elf shoes all December OR wear a Santa hat all December
  • Find a gift under your pillow OR find one inside your stocking
  • Ride in Santa's sleigh OR visit an elf workshop
  • Make toys with elves OR care for flying reindeer
  • Eat a candy-cane breakfast OR a cookie dinner
  • Control Christmas lights OR control falling snow
  • Talk to snowmen OR talk to reindeer
  • Open one gift early OR choose the first holiday movie
  • Decorate with only red OR decorate with only green
  • Have tinsel hair OR ornament earrings
  • Sleep in a treehouse at the North Pole OR in a castle made of ice
  • Deliver gifts by sleigh OR by magical train
  • Receive ten tiny presents OR one enormous present
  • Build a snowman that sings OR a gingerbread person that dances
  • Wear jingle-bell shoes OR a blinking jumper
  • Find the hidden pickle ornament OR hide it for everyone else
  • Drink endless cocoa OR eat endless marshmallows
  • Be the star on the tree OR the angel on top

Christmas Would You Rather for families

  • Host the whole family OR travel to someone else's house
  • Cook the main meal OR wash every dish
  • Choose the tree OR choose all the decorations
  • Exchange handmade gifts OR experience gifts
  • Start presents before breakfast OR after the main meal
  • Keep one old tradition OR invent a new one
  • Spend the day indoors by a fire OR outdoors in fresh snow
  • Have a perfectly quiet morning OR a loud house full of guests
  • Take one perfect family photo OR no photos at all
  • Plan every detail OR let the day happen naturally
  • Use real candles OR hundreds of electric lights
  • Serve everyone's favorite side OR one spectacular dessert
  • Watch a childhood favorite OR try a new festive movie
  • Call every relative OR write every relative a card
  • Have matching pajamas OR matching festive jumpers
  • Keep the decorations minimalist OR cover every room
  • Sing carols together OR play a family game tournament
  • Eat leftovers for three days OR send every leftover home
  • Share one long table OR several small tables
  • Open stockings together OR whenever each person wakes up

Funny Christmas party questions

  • Untangle every light string OR assemble every toy
  • Wear an ugly jumper to work OR antlers on every video call
  • Be followed by carol singers OR by a marching toy band
  • Wrap gifts with oven gloves OR decorate cookies blindfolded
  • Give the wrong gift to the right person OR the right gift to the wrong person
  • Have glitter on everything OR pine needles on everything
  • Dance whenever a bell rings OR sing whenever someone says Christmas
  • Carry a life-size cardboard Santa OR a giant inflatable snowman
  • Eat only round festive foods OR only red and green foods
  • Tell the same cracker joke all day OR hear the same carol all day
  • Get stuck in a chimney OR stuck inside a giant present
  • Have a tree that sheds snow OR a wreath that sings
  • Wear socks on your hands OR mittens on your feet
  • Use tape that never tears OR paper that tears too easily
  • Accidentally switch every name tag OR forget every gift receipt
  • Be responsible for party music OR party photos
  • Sit beside the loudest guest OR the sleepiest guest
  • Clean up wrapping paper OR clean up confetti
  • Receive a mystery food hamper OR a mystery novelty jumper
  • Explain a strange tradition OR invent a believable one

Hard Christmas choices

  • Give up gifts for a year OR give up festive food for a year
  • Know every gift in advance OR be surprised by everything
  • Repeat your favorite Christmas OR create a completely new one
  • Spend the season without music OR without decorations
  • Only give practical gifts OR only give funny gifts
  • Travel somewhere new OR return to the place with the best memories
  • Host friends OR reserve the day for family
  • Keep celebrations small OR invite everyone you know
  • Have unlimited time but a small budget OR unlimited budget but one hour to prepare
  • Receive exactly what you asked for OR something unforgettable you never expected
  • Remember every detail of past holidays OR preview the next ten
  • Guarantee perfect weather OR guarantee everyone arrives on time
  • Cook one flawless dish OR make every dish reasonably well
  • Have a private snowy view OR a lively city celebration
  • Give one person a life-changing gift OR give everyone a thoughtful small gift
  • Keep every decoration forever OR replace the theme each year
  • Hear honest reactions to every gift OR never know what anyone thought
  • Pause Christmas morning for an hour OR replay Christmas evening once
  • Spend the day completely offline OR share every moment live
  • End the season rested OR end it with one unforgettable story

Before you start

Questions, answered.

What are good Christmas Would You Rather questions?

Good questions compare two related festive choices: gifts, food, decorating, travel, traditions, holiday powers, or party jobs. Both options should feel equally tempting or inconvenient.

Are these Christmas questions suitable for kids?

Yes. The entire page and playable Christmas category are family-safe. The first group is easiest for children, while the harder group suits older players.

How do you play Christmas Would You Rather?

Read both options, make everyone choose before discussion starts, then ask a few players to defend their side. Draw another card when the debate slows.

Can we play online or on a video call?

Yes. Share the browser, read each card aloud, and let players vote with chat, reactions, hands, or separate sides of the screen.

Can I print the 80 questions?

Yes. Print the page for a screen-free game, or use the generator when the group wants fresh Christmas choices.

Keep exploring

Related games and guides.

Play Christmas Would You Rather

Christmas party games

Choose seated, active, printable, office, and shared-screen options.

Christmas charades

Act out 60 festive prompts or open the themed generator.

Christmas Categories game

Race through eight original letter-and-list rounds.